Skip navigation

Ex-President Carter discusses book with rabbis

Many angered by controversial description of Mideast conflict as ‘apartheid’

FREE VIDEO
Carter on Israeli 'apartheid'
Dec. 3: Former President Jimmy Carter tells Tim Russert of NBC's 'Meet the Press' that he considers some Israel policies toward Palestinians comparable to South African Apartheid.

Meet the Press

Multimedia stories
Image: The White House Debuts The Obamas' New Dog Bo, A Portuguese Water Dog
Getty Images
  Who’s a good Bo?
See the Obama family’s frisky new Portuguese water dog pup, Bo, sink his paws into his classy new digs: the White House.
Pete Souza
  Inside Obama's White House
Get a glimpse of President Barack Obama's first 100 days, through the lens of photographer Pete Souza.
Image: Amy Carter goes to school
AP
  First sons and daughters
Under many administrations, the corridors of the White House have resounded with the patter of little feet.
Image: Michelle Obama
AP
  Michelle Obama's effortless style
The first lady looks as sophisticated in designer dresses as she does in outfits from J. Crew.
  Police to talk with Woods after crash
Nov. 28: Florida officials are hoping the golfer can provide some answers as to what caused his car to hit a fire hydrant and a tree in his neighbor’s yard after he pulled out of his driveway at 2:25 a.m. NBC’s Mark Potter reports.

updated 1:15 p.m. ET Dec. 13, 2006

PHOENIX - Former President Jimmy Carter prayed with rabbis who are angered by his new book’s reference to apartheid in describing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but he didn’t change their minds.

The Board of Rabbis of Greater Phoenix said they wouldn’t call for a boycott of Carter’s book, “Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid,” but they also won’t suggest that anyone read it.

“I don’t know if he gets the evil that we are facing,” said Rabbi Bonnie Koppell of Scottsdale.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Carter, 82, was met by a crowd of protesters as he appeared at a book store in suburban Tempe to autograph copies of the book.

He said he chose the title to shine light on the festering conflict and give Americans a different point of view than what they’re used to.

“I wanted to provoke debate,” Carter said. “I wanted to provoke discussion.”

Carter’s book follows the peace negotiations between the Israelis and Palestinians during his presidency in 1977-1980. He’s critical of all players in not reaching a better accord, but he’s especially critical of the Israelis. He previously told The Associated Press that Americans are rarely exposed to anything other than pro-Israeli views in the news media.

Koppell said Carter’s word choice was “gratuitously provocative” and meant to add fuel to an already incendiary subject and sell more books.

“I don’t really see the book as helpful,” said Koppell, who has read it.

Carter met with the rabbis’ group for almost an hour, prayed with them and invited them to help him teach Sunday school.

Koppell said she was surprised that he spent so much time with them and felt he would try to be more balanced in the future.

Rabbi Ayla Grafstein of Scottsdale said it didn’t matter what promises Carter made.

“In the end, he’s not going to change what’s in his book,” Grafstein said.

© 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Sponsored links

Resource guide