One game, three platforms: Which is best?

Keyboard, mouse among PC's virtues
The mention of “Quake 4” leads to PC gaming and one of its greatest virtues: The keyboard and mouse. Fans of first-person shooters played the original “Quake” in front of a PC with a keyboard and mouse to control the action long before the genre arrived on console machines. Handling a controller to play the mega-hit “Halo” for the original Xbox felt positively bizarre to me – and still does when I play FPS games on the next-gen Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3.

Personally, I prefer the quicker, tighter feeling the mouse offers to a console controller. At one point I hooked up a third-party device that allowed me to use a keyboard and mouse to play “Halo.” Guess what? Players who cut their FPS teeth on the console were still faster, better shots than me. So much for my theory that the keyboard and mouse combo would give me a competitive advantage over players stuck with the controller.

Those PC players that actually prefer playing by controller can add one, whereas they cannot readily do the opposite and add a keyboard and mouse to their boxes. I say not readily because mice and keyboards are not natively supported on most consoles. However, there are solutions.

To add mouse-and-keyboardability to the Xbox 360, try the  $80 Team Xtender XCM XFPS 360 – although without hands-on time with the device I cannot attest to its usability. For the PS3, a more innovative hybrid, the Splitfish FragFX, combines left-controller movement with a right-hand mouse and built-in mousepad combo that’s designed to rest comfortably in the lap ($59.99 for wired, and $69.99 for Bluetooth wireless version). Again, I haven’t gotten my hands on one of these yet, but early reports give it high marks for bringing mouse control to the console.

The keyboard and mouse are critical when playing MMORPG PC games like “World of Warcraft” and “Everquest,” or strategy games like “Lord of the Rings: Battle for Middle Earth II.” With a mouse, numerous commands are a click or keystroke away, and in “Lord of the Rings,” selecting groups of warriors is only a mouse-click-and-drag away. Pulling off the same action on the Xbox 360 version feels ham-handed and numb by comparison.

Graphics hardware adds to PC advantage
The other big PC gaming plus is graphics hardware. Unlike consoles, which are bound to the same graphics hardware for a 3 to 5 year lifecycle, PCs can be upgraded with more powerful video cards that offer superior graphics. Case in point: Running “Oblivion” on my aging Alienware PC served up the best-looking experience of all — once I got the ATI Radeon X 1950 Pro working. Which brings up a major PC minus: Getting the latest drivers to work involved numerous installs, crashes, and restarts to Safe mode to troubleshoot and tweak.

ATI released a newer driver, but the system still crashes often, making it impossible to get in any extended time with “Oblivion.” This is most likely due to the aging PC and not the card itself.

...but, PC gaming is pricier
Of course, a newer PC with Vista-certified-everything would likely work smoothly from the start – but whether it’s a better video card for your existing PC or a new, screaming-fast box tuned for gaming, PC gaming costs more than console gaming. The Radeon X1950 Pro I tested retails for about $250, which is more than half the price of an Xbox 360, and tricked out gamer PCs range can cost $1000 to $5000 – or more.

The PC version of “Oblivion” enjoys the same downloadable add-ons as the Xbox 360 version, and then some: Players can access plug-ins and mods, both official and unofficial, that change the experience in ways neither console version can hold a sword to. The ability to mod games has long been one of the PC’s greatest virtues as a gaming platform. And though it can’t really be called a game, one visit to the alternate reality known as Second Life is a living example of just how inventive (and bizarre) a world can be when it is flexible and open to creative interpretation.

Will Home change the playing field?
While Second Life doesn’t exist for consoles, it may turn out that the PlayStation 3 will bridge the console and-virtual-life worlds when Sony releases Home, its virtual community enhancement.

Preview details of Home describe customizable alter-ego avatars, theaters for watching virtual movie and game trailers and trophy halls for displaying  gaming achievements. As for PC and console gamers duking it out in the same arena, Microsoft’s "Shadowrun," which ships at the end of the month, will pit the two sides against one another via Xbox Live.

Who will prove to be the better gamer — the PC player behind keyboard and mouse, or the 360 shooter kicked back on the sofa? That remains to be seen — quite literally, since Xbox Live’s gamer profile stats show how players stack up against one another from game to game.

Sure, each side of the debate can tout its superiority over the other, but in the end, a gamer’s "Shadowrun" achievement points will speak for themselves.

May the "best" platform win.

MORE FROM TECHNOLOGY & MONEY

Technology & Money Section Front

Gallery: Your latest splurges Facebook: ‘Why not give your ex another shot?’ Is Twitter the news outlet for the 21st century?   Advice on mortgage payments Get your ‘Thriller’ on YouTube   Stolen items up for grabs allDAY: Which TODAY anchor do you follow on Twitter?   What are your mileage points worth? Spears, DeGeneres Twitpic accounts hacked   Texting while driving worse than DUI? Technology & Money Section Front   Add Technology & Money headlines to your news reader: