Skip navigation

Police reveal interrogation of missing tot’s mom

Questioners accuse Casey Anthony of lying on newly released tapes

Video
  New police tapes of tot’s mom
Sept. 15: Investigators have released new audio tapes of Casey Anthony, the mother of missing Florida toddler Caylee Anthony. NBC’s Dan Abrams weighs in on the recordings.

Today show

Special feature
Tales of survival
A gator victim who got a new high-tech hand; a mom who woke from a coma; a police officer who flatlined twice. Learn how all these people and others came through life-threatening situations.
Slideshow
Image: A fan in Times Square reacts to a play while watching the New York Yankees play the Philadelphia Phillies in Game 6 before going on to win the 2009 Major League Baseball World Series in New York
  The Week in Pictures
Yankees fans, Pakistan train crash, festival of lights, Iran protest, rodeo clowns, H1N1, toddler bowling and more news and feature photos from around the globe.

more photos

  Big changes in store for Oprah?
Nov. 8: Is the queen of daytime television preparing to give up her popular talk show to focus on her own cable network? NBC’s Kevin Tibbles reports, then Rolling Stone contributor Toure and CNBC’s Carmen Wong Ulrich join Jenna Wolfe to discuss the financial and cultural impact of a potential move.

In the news
Image:
AP
  Philippines pounded again
View images of the fourth major typhoon faced by the country in four weeks.
Image: Major Shannon Cole
PANOS
  Saving lives on the front line
Photographer Erin Trieb spends six weeks with the U.S. Army's busiest trauma center in Afghanistan.
Image: Atleast 70 mostly women and children killed in a bomb blast in Peshawar
EPA
  Deadly blast in Peshawar market
A powerful bomb rips through a crowded bazaar in Peshawar, Pakistan.
Image: A victim of the two car bombs targeting the Ministry of Justice and the Baghdad Provincial Council receives medical aid at the hospital in Baghdad
Reuters
  Two blasts rock Baghdad
Powerful car bombs targeting city government office buildings kill more than 130.
By Mike Celizic
TODAYShow.com contributor
updated 10:00 a.m. ET Sept. 15, 2008

In an apparent effort to ratchet up the heat on Casey Anthony, the mother of missing Orlando, Fla., toddler Caylee Anthony, police have released interview tapes that, they say, show that Anthony repeatedly lied to them.

“Everything you've told us is a lie! Every single thing!” an investigator shouts at Anthony during questioning that took place on July 16, a month after the 22-year-old single mother first revealed Caylee, who would now be 3 years old, was missing. Police had been alerted to the disappearance by Anthony’s mother, Cindy Anthony.

“If the main thing you want to do is find your daughter, and you don’t think lying to us is gonna help find her, why would you do that?” an investigator asks on the tapes.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

“Because I'm scared, and I know I’m running out of options.  It’s been a month,” Anthony replies. Later, she again talks about her fear: “I’m scared, that I don't know where my daughter is.”

“This is the story you want to stick with?” her interrogator asks.

“It's the truth,” Anthony insists. “It's the story I will stick with. Yes.” On the tapes, she continues to maintain she’s telling the truth even after police point to facts that show her statements as falsehoods.

Turning up the heat
“The practical reality is they are turning up the heat on her,” NBC News chief legal correspondent Dan Abrams told TODAY’s Meredith Vieira Tuesday after listening to excerpts from the tapes. “They are looking for everything and anything to say to her: ‘You’d better work with us, because we think that we’ve got a lot of evidence against you.’ ”

Anthony, who is free on $500,000 bail and living with her parents, has maintained that a baby sitter named Zenaida Fernandez Gonzalez took Caylee, although police have been unable to find anyone meeting such a person’s description. The apartment at which Anthony said she dropped Caylee off proved to be an unoccupied unit. They also determined that Anthony no longer worked at the company she gave as her place of employment.

Police initially arrested Anthony. After she was released on bail, they charged her with numerous counts of stealing checks from friends and using them to make purchases. Groups of demonstrators have taken to gathering outside her parents’ home, yelling at family members as they leave and enter the property, prompting appeals to the courts by neighbors who say their peace and quiet have been shattered.

Abrams said that the tapes can be considered public records, but added that it is unusual to release such evidence while an investigation is ongoing. He said it is also evident that investigators don’t have enough evidence to charge Anthony in connection with the disappearance of her daughter.

Image: Dan Abrams
TODAY
NBC News chief legal correspondent Dan Abrams comments on the ongoing investigation into the disappearance of Caylee Anthony.

“If they had enough they would charge her. They don’t quite have enough to charge,” Abrams told Vieira. “There’s no question that these authorities want to charge her. Look at what they’ve done already. They’re charging her for using checks. They’re [charging] her for child neglect. They’re putting the heat on her, and if they had it, they would charge her.”

Sole suspect?
Investigators say that they are looking at all possibilities, but the reality, Abrams continued, is that Anthony is probably the sole suspect.

“It’s clear she’s not telling the truth. That’s important. The question is why? Why wouldn’t she tell the truth?” he said. “Why wouldn’t she offer the authorities any help in finding her daughter?”

Police have said they’re treating the disappearance as a homicide. In a court hearing earlier this week, investigators said they found Casey Anthony’s car abandoned in a parking lot in late
Caylee Anthony has been missing for months.

June. The interior of the vehicle had a strong smell of decomposition, and a dog trained to find cadavers indicated the smell was from human remains. Investigators said they found a stain in the trunk and hair that may have come from Caylee.

Casey Anthony said that she left the car in the parking lot when it ran out of gas. She and her mother said the bad smell was from a piece of pizza that had been left in the trunk and rotted.

Investigators say that Casey Anthony has repeatedly lied to them about everything from the whereabouts of the child’s father to her employment history.

Meanwhile, Anthony’s parents have repeatedly said they’re continuing to track down leads to find their granddaughter, whom they insist was kidnapped.

© 2009 MSNBC Interactive.  Reprints

Sponsored links

Resource guide