1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: Embryo mix-up is one woman’s miracle

  1. Transcript of: Embryo mix-up is one woman’s miracle

    MEREDITH VIEIRA, co-host: Back now at 8:09 with TODAY'S UPDATE . Last September we first brought you the story of a terrible embryo mix-up. Two families who had placed their trust in the high-tech world of fertility treatment , betrayed by the science that was supposed to bring them joy. We're going to talk with the Morell family in just a moment, but first how their story unfolded.

    Ms. SHANNON MORELL: He said, `Your embryos were implanted into another woman. And I just went, ` Ah! ' And I just fell back in the -- in the couch.

    VIEIRA: How could this have happened? It was the first question Michigan couple Shannon and Paul Morell had when they heard the news the extra embryos they had frozen at a fertility clinic three years prior had been implanted into a total stranger. And that stranger was now pregnant. The next question, who was carrying their child? One hundred fifty miles away in Ohio , Carolyn and Sean Savage were just learning the baby they had so desperately hoped for was not theirs.

    Mr. SEAN SAVAGE: I was sitting in my office and about 4:00 received a call from the physician who performed the transfer. He let me know at that moment in almost one sentence that Carolyn was pregnant but they had thawed and transferred another couple's embryos.

    Ms. CAROLYN SAVAGE: So I was upstairs in my bedroom and he came through the door and he just said, `I have really bad news.' And I kind of sat up. He said, `You're pregnant, but they transferred the wrong embryos.'

    VIEIRA: It was devastating news for both families. For Carolyn Savage this could be her last change to become pregnant. And for Shannon Morell , robbed of her chance to carry her last child. But the thought lingered, would Carolyn Savage agree to take on the health risks of pregnancy for a child who would never be hers? It turned out she would.

    Ms. MORELL: There's now way we could possibly repay them for what they've done, because you can't put a price on human life .

    VIEIRA: The Savages had only one request for the Morells and the son they would never really know.

    Ms. SAVAGE: We want a moment to say hello and goodbye.

    VIEIRA: And the Savages did say goodbye to little Logan Morell the day he was born, as the Morells said hello to a lifetime with their son.

    Ms. SAVAGE: We will wonder about this child every day for the rest of our lives. And we have hopes for him. But they're his parents and we'll defer to their judgment. You know, we just want to know he's happy and healthy.

    VIEIRA: Paul and Shannon Morell have now written a book about this

    extraordinary experience called, "Misconception: One Couple's Journey from Embryo Mix -up to Miracle Baby ." They are with us, along with a very sleepy baby Logan . Good morning to you all.

    Ms. MORELL: Good morning.

    Mr. PAUL MORELL: Good morning.

    VIEIRA: As we just heard in that piece, Carolyn Savage said all that she hoped for was that Logan be happy and healthy. He obviously looks quite happy to me. Content, to say the least .

    Ms. MORELL: Yes, yes.

    Mr. MORELL: Yes.

    VIEIRA: Talk to me about him. How's he doing?

    Ms. MORELL: He's doing great. He's doing wonderful. Like you say, I mean, he's healthy, he's a -- he's a happy baby . He's well loved by his sisters.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: So we have been blessed.

    Mr. MORELL: Low maintenance .

    VIEIRA: Low maintenance so far.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    VIEIRA: Yeah. Well, right now extremely low maintenance . You mentioned his sister. You have twin daughters ...

    Ms. MORELL: Uh-huh.

    VIEIRA: ...Ellie and Megan. They were conceived three years ago...

    Ms. MORELL: Yep.

    VIEIRA: ...as part of that same set of embryos.

    Ms. MORELL: Mm-hmm.

    VIEIRA: And they get along with their little brother.

    Mr. MORELL: Oh, yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: Love him. Love him.

    Mr. MORELL: Like to take care of him. Yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: Especially now that he gives them feedback. They'll go over and sing to him and he can sense...

    VIEIRA: What is he, seven months at this point?

    Ms. MORELL: Seven months.

    VIEIRA: Seven months.

    Ms. MORELL: Yep. Yep.

    VIEIRA: Why was it important this early on to write this book?

    Mr. MORELL: Well, we feel that, you know, there were so many things that were happening, wanted to turn a negative into a positive. And not only to help other couples that were out there, we wish we had this book, you know, before we experienced what we did. And we thought it would be a tremendous help, you know, for a lot of people.

    VIEIRA: Yeah. Why do you say that you wish you had it before you experienced what did you? Do you have mixed feelings about IVF now, or...

    Ms. MORELL: No, no. I'm a strong advocate of IVF .

    VIEIRA: Yeah. Yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: I say go ahead and do it. We have three great kids because of it. But it's a cautionary tale because I thought I was prepared. I thought I asked lots of questions, but now I know more. And I guess I always thought, you know, this is -- it's a great story and a lot of people should know, you know, how great Carolyn is...

    Mr. MORELL: Mm-hmm.

    Ms. MORELL: ...and for what she did, and that we're blessed. But the story 's bigger than just our story . I learned so much that hopefully will help other couples when they're looking at, you know, how do I choose an IVF clinic and what are some questions I should ask.

    Mr. MORELL: Mm-hmm.

    VIEIRA: Yeah. Did you end up suing the clinic or what happened?

    Ms. MORELL: No, we reached a settlement with the clinic.

    VIEIRA: You reached a settlement with them.

    Ms. MORELL: Mm-hmm.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    VIEIRA: You know, you -- essentially this book is a thank-you note to the Savages .

    Ms. MORELL: Mm-hmm.

    VIEIRA: You write, "Thank you for nurturing our son, protecting him, most of all loving him enough to let him go."

    Ms. MORELL: Mm-hmm. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. What is your relationship with the Savages now, and what is their relationship with Logan ?

    Mr. MORELL: Well, I mean, they're like extended family . We keep in contact. And whatever their schedule is, whatever they want to do, we'll be happy to accommodate and if they want to visit...

    Ms. MORELL: We send e-mail...

    Mr. MORELL: ...and e-mail.

    Ms. MORELL: ...and photos and so forth. And we're just glad that they're willing to continue to have a relationship so one day he'll know who they are.

    VIEIRA: Yeah. They sent us a statement and they said, "We would like to thank everyone for their continued thoughts, prayers and support. Unfortunately, these past seven months have been much more difficult for us than anticipated."

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    VIEIRA: Their story is going to be much different than yours, obviously.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah, yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: Mm-hmm. Definitely. Two different -- same scenario, but different effects on both families.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah. What we went through was -- it was very, very difficult, but what she had to go through and what Sean had to go through must have been just, you know...

    Ms. MORELL: Well, carrying a -- a pregnancy isn't easy.

    VIEIRA: Yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: And then to say goodbye and be in the hospital and we're taking the baby home. That would be hard.

    VIEIRA: It had to be hard for all of you, I'm sure.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: Mm-hmm.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    VIEIRA: When do you think you're going to tell Logan about the way he came into the world? And how will you tell him?

    Mr. MORELL: Well, I think when he starts asking questions and...

    Ms. MORELL: I think a little bit at a time.

    Mr. MORELL: A little bit, yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: I don't have the exact answer. I think as a parent you'll know what's right to give him enough.

    Mr. MORELL: When he starts to get curious. You know, why.

    Ms. MORELL: And you make it seem like although it was -- we don't want him to think it was a horrific, terrible experience, that it's part of God's plan , and that he's been blessed. He was loved by two families. And...

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah. He might be crawling on the floor and see his picture in the book and go, `what's that?'

    Ms. MORELL: You never know. No. No. And to make it seem like it's perfectly natural.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    VIEIRA: Well, he's a beautiful little boy and the story does have a very positive outcome.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    Ms. MORELL: Yeah, it does.

    Mr. MORELL: Yeah.

    VIEIRA: Shannon and Paul , thank you so much . I put every guy to sleep , I'm telling you. I don't know what it is. The book is...

By
TODAY.com contributor
updated 5/4/2010 10:17:31 AM ET 2010-05-04T14:17:31

Someday, the little boy known as baby Logan will come to know about the extraordinary circumstances of his birth.

  1. More from TODAY.com
    1. Jilted groom suing for $61K: ‘I tried to be a nice guy’

      Steven Silverstein, who has made headlines for suing Kendra Platt-Lee for costs related to their canceled wedding and seve...

    2. Pitbull heats up plaza with ‘Love’
    3. Michelle Parker’s mom: Her kids are ‘not the same’
    4. Bobby Brown’s kids talk about his drug use
    5. Bobbie's Buzz: Unique and clever cocktail helpers

For the moment, the perfect little infant, dressed in plaid pants, a white polo shirt and sweater vest, remains blissfully ignorant of the international news he created, not to mention the emotional turmoil that accompanied his arrival in the world.

“He’s doing great. He’s doing wonderful. He’s healthy. He’s a happy baby,” his proud mom, Shannon Morell, told TODAY’s Meredith Vieira Tuesday in New York as her husband, Paul, cradled the nattily attired little boy, who slept serenely through his moment on network TV.

Logan was born just seven months ago, the result of a colossal mix-up at a fertility clinic that had implanted embryos belonging to Shannon and Paul Morell into another woman, Carolyn Savage. After first communicating anonymously through their lawyers, the Morells and Savages became friends and went through most of the pregnancy together.

After Logan’s birth, the Savages were given time to say hello and goodbye to the baby Carolyn had carried in her womb. Then they handed him over to the Morells. The couples, separated by about 150 miles, remain close and share e-mails, pictures and news about Logan. They also visited over the Christmas holidays.

Unusual bond
Both families would learn that their bond is unusual among the rare cases when women have been implanted with the wrong embryos. Most often, experts say, the cases end in bitter lawsuits, custody battles and even abortions.

The cases are so rare and so jarring that the story was news around the world, and both the Savages and the Morells made appearances on TODAY in the days before Logan was born slightly prematurely last September.

Now, the Morells have written a book about their miracle baby, “Misconception: One Couple’s Journey From Embryo Mix-Up to Miracle Baby,” and hope that their experiences will help others entering the world of in vitro fertilization (IVF).

“We want to turn a negative to a positive, to help other couples who are out there,” Paul Morell told Vieira. “We wish we had this book when we experienced what we did. We thought it would be a tremendous help to a lot of people.”

The Morells said their message is not to avoid IVF. They have 3-year-old twin daughters who were born through the procedure as well as Logan.

‘A cautionary tale’
“I say go ahead and do it. We have three great kids because of it,” Shannon Morell said. But, she added, couples contemplating IVF should be aware of the possible pitfalls and know what questions to ask of a prospective clinic.

“It’s a cautionary tale because I thought I was prepared. I thought I asked lots of questions. Now, I know more,” Shannon told Vieira. “We’re blessed. But the story’s bigger than just our story. There’s so much that hopefully will help other couples.”

The Morells said they are particularly anxious to make sure that others know the sacrifice that Carolyn Savage made for Logan. Carolyn had a history of difficult pregnancies and when she was implanted with the wrong embryo, she knew it was the last pregnancy she would be able to safely endure. She and her husband wanted another child, but after Logan’s birth she would be unable to bear that child.

TODAY
Shannon and Paul Morell have three children conceived through IVF. They say they still advocate the procedure.

In a statement to TODAY, Carolyn and Sean Savage said they’re not yet prepared to talk about their experience with Logan, but are writing a book to be published in 2011.

“We would like to thank everyone for their continued thoughts, prayers, and support. Unfortunately, these past seven months have been much more difficult for us than anticipated. As a result, we are still trying to gain perspective on this life-changing event. We will share our story in early 2011. Until then, we pray Logan Morell grows to understand his birth was a blessing and his life a gift,” the statement said.

Extended family
The Morells are grateful for the Savages’ graciousness.

Video: Woman implanted with wrong embryo

“They’re like extended family. We keep in contact. Whatever their schedule is, whatever they want to do, we’ll be happy to accommodate,” Paul Morell said.

“We’re just happy that they’re willing to continue to have a relationship so one day he’ll know who they are,” Shannon said, adding that one reason for writing the book is to let people know what extraordinary people the Savages are.

“Carrying a pregnancy isn’t easy. To say goodbye and be in the hospital and we’re taking the baby home — it had to be hard,” Shannon said. “A lot of people should know how great Carolyn is and what she did.”

The Morells aren’t sure how they’ll tell Logan about how he came to exist. “I think a little bit at a time,” Shannon said. She added that the infant will know that it was all very positive.

“It’s part of God’s plan and he’s been blessed. He’s loved by two families.” she said. “We’re going to make it sound as if it’s perfectly natural.”

© 2012 MSNBC Interactive.  Reprints

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

More on TODAY.com

None
  1. Retired cop: I know Zodiac Killer’s name

    video A former California highway patrolman has written a book in which he claims a 91-year-old man who died this year was the famed Zodiac Killer, who killed at least five people in the San Francisco area in the 1960s. NBC’s Mike Taibbi reports.

    5/26/2012 2:42:50 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:42:50
None
  1. TODAY

    video Do crying babies make you sharper?

    5/26/2012 2:39:26 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:39:26
None
  1. Biographer says prince scarred by parent’s marriage

    video The author of a new book about the life of Prince William says that the royal most likely to ascend to the throne was scarred by his parent’s marital problems, and long-believed he might not ever settle down. NBC’s Duncan Golestani reports.

    5/26/2012 5:36:22 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T17:36:22
None
  1. TODAY

    video ‘Hunger Games’ comes to life?

    5/26/2012 2:46:43 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:46:43
None
  1. Stuntman falls 2,400 feet without chute

    video TODAY’s Jenna Wolfe speaks with stuntman Gary Connery, the first person to drop out of a helicopter wearing a “wing suit” and land without deploying a parachute.

    5/26/2012 2:45:01 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:45:01
None
  1. Is suspect in Etan Patz murder sane?

    video A lawyer for a 51-year-old New Jersey man accused of killing 6-year-old Etan Patz in New York City 33 years ago says his client has mental health problems that may come into play during his prosecution. Former FBI profiler Clint van Zandt discusses the case.

    5/26/2012 2:49:53 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:49:53