1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: Half of men would leave their partners if they gained weight

  1. Closed captioning of: Half of men would leave their partners if they gained weight

    >>> recent poll nearly 50% of men say they would dump their partner if she gained too much weight. nicole is the executive editor of "cosmopolitan" magazine and robi ludwig is contributor to care.com. ladies, we are shocked. cosmo did this survey of 80,000 men. men who are basically not married yet, though. they're boyfriend and girlfriend. this was the result. half of them.

    >> askmen.com, did a joint survey. 80,000 people overall. this horrifying stat, they said 50% of guys said they would leave their partner if she were to gain significant weight. i'm five months pregnant, reading this is very alarming. i'm taking it as a not so gentle reminder that no matter how in love a man is, physical attraction always remains very important to him.

    >> and, where do you think this is coming from, that men feel that the relationship can dissolve so much based on that physical attraction ?

    >> men are statistically a lot more focused on looks and body type. and it does matter to them, because in part they feel that who they're with is a statement about who they are. so if they're with somebody who doesn't look good, what does that say about them? they have low self-esteem, they're not successful? plen a men are a little bit more focus and what their women look like.

    >> it's also about weight. i think that for men some are thinking if she gains a lot of weight it means she no longer cares about her appearance, which means she no longer cares about being sexually attracted to me which means we're never going to have sex again.

    >> interesting thing is studies show that a woman who is obsessed with her weight isn't necessarily more sexual. if she feels good about herself, that can increase her sexuality.

    >> meanwhile, women are much more forgiving, thank god, in this survey. apparently 20% of women would dump their boyfriend if he gained weight. i guess we give a little more in that department.

    >> right. there are other parts of the survey that show that men were less for giving for themselves. when it comes a certain part of their anatomy, majority of men would like to be a little bit bigger and that jmajority are happy. men are hard on themselves, too.

    >> when it comes to the message the survey says to women in terms of self-esteem, what does this tell us, nicole? besides, get to the gym now, do zumba on the plaza.

    >> the message for me and i think most women should take away is just the physical attraction and sexuality is important to the relationship. they call it intimacy for a reason. if you lose that, the relationship will suffer maybe more for the men than women . self-esteem, being at the weight that makes you feel happy and comfortable and sexy. that's going to make you feel the best.

    >> there is a weight discrimination in our country and it has increased by 66% over the last ten years.

    >> is it equal men to women , that weight discrimination? it doesn't seem to matter so much when a man puts on weight.

    >> it does. it does affect men in the job market, in terms of dating. women , it affects them a little bit more because that's in part what we bring to the table, how we look. and i think we just have to understand that reality. there is a study done that had a man pictured with a heavyset woman that same man pictured with a thin woman. and the man with the heavier woman, there was a more negative response to. so i mean, i think looks impacts us.

    >> if there is some redemption here, there is a part of the survey that i think is interesting, where 26% of women say having a successful partner is the ultimate status symbol . meanwhile, 39% of men say family is the ultimate status symbol . it sounds like when they're in a committed relationship and ready to start a family -- they do like to be in that committed relationship and will stay.

    >> i think it's important that women not get too comfortable and think, well, he loves me, we've been together for a long time, we have kids together, it doesn't matter anymore.

    >> and couples should help each other to be their best physically, emotionally.

    >> lie.

    >> no, they don't.

    >> twice as big as they used to be and lie to your face, no, honey, we love you.

    >> they want to love you into beauty. that's the key.

    >> all right. well, ladies, the discussion is certainly -- it's pretty unbelievable when you look at all the statistics from

By
TODAY.com contributor
updated 8/3/2011 9:14:00 AM ET 2011-08-03T13:14:00

Women, do you want to stay married? Then you better not get fat.

  1. More from TODAY.com
    1. Jilted groom suing for $61K: ‘I tried to be a nice guy’

      Steven Silverstein, who has made headlines for suing Kendra Platt-Lee for costs related to their canceled wedding and seve...

    2. Pitbull heats up plaza with ‘Love’
    3. Michelle Parker’s mom: Her kids are ‘not the same’
    4. Bobby Brown’s kids talk about his drug use
    5. Bobbie's Buzz: Unique and clever cocktail helpers

At least, that's if you believe a recent poll that questioned 70,000 men about what they would do if their partners gained weight. Almost half the men said they would leave their partners if they gained too much weight, compared to only 20 percent of the women who responded to this poll.

Is it time to modernize our vows to include, “For thinner or for fatter?”

As a clinician, I can honestly say I have not seen these poll findings play out with the couples I treat in my private practice. Most of the women I encounter are far harder on themselves about their weight and looks than the men in their lives. Having said that, various studies seem to suggest men are more focused on appearance, and place far greater emphasis on a woman’s looks and body type, than women do.

It’s no secret women are objectified more often than men are: Women’s bodies are more often looked at, evaluated and sexualized. There is an undeniable weight bias and obsession in our culture, too. Whenever a famous singer or actor gains a few extra pounds, it becomes instant headline news. The media is on top of these stories almost as soon as these celebrities get off the scale.

According to the Journal of Obesity, weight discrimination, especially targeting women, is increasing in the US. In fact, the statistics show that discrimination based on weight has increased 66 percent in the past decade. And in a survey of 400 female Marie Claire readers, 77 percent acknowledged having the thought, “How did she get him?” when seeing an obese woman walk by with an average-weight partner.

But this still doesn’t explain why a man would leave his partner if she gets fat. What does “getting fat” mean to this type of man?

Perhaps some men care what their partner looks like because a partner becomes an extension of themselves, and how they want to be seen by the world. An obese partner could send the message that he’s a man who has a poor self-esteem or is not successful. A study conducted at the University of Liverpool found a man photographed with a heavy-set woman was rated 22 percent more negatively than that same man with a thin woman.

Some men want women to be in sync with them when it comes to health and fitness. If they care about how they look, they want their partner to feel the same. Perhaps it’s about feeling sexually attracted: When a person gains a lot of weight, sometimes they don’t look as healthy, feel as confident and can loose a sense of pride in themselves, which influences how sexy they look and feel.

Now after stating all of the above, whatever happened to couples working together to keep each other on track emotionally and physically? Shouldn’t couples help each other to be and look their very best? What about communicating one’s wishes and preferences in a relationship, instead of jumping ship and acting out, as soon as they become disappointed? If weight and looks are important to a man (or a woman, for that matter), fine! Then help your partner figure out how they can be healthy and look good for you. Seems like a far better way to go, especially since this poll also found that men say the ultimate status symbol to be their families.

Dr. Robi Ludwig is a psychotherapist and a regular contributor to TODAY. She is co-author of "’Till Death Do Us Part: Love, Marriage and the Mind of the Killer Spouse."

© 2012 MSNBC Interactive.  Reprints

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

More on TODAY.com

None
  1. Still in gear: Injuries don’t stop veterans on 100-day bike trek

    They knew their cross-country ride to raise awareness about veteran suicides would be hard. What they didn’t realize was how much their journey would rejuvenate them — even though it involved so much injury.

    5/25/2012 6:21:37 PM +00:00 2012-05-25T18:21:37
  2. Military women and suicide: Home safe but not sound

    Increased rates of suicide among females in the military — once out of harm's way — point to how deep and inescapable their emotional wounds can be.

    5/25/2012 6:23:41 PM +00:00 2012-05-25T18:23:41
  3. walltowallbicycleride.com
Yum
  1. The great Cuban sandwich debate

    5/25/2012 8:39:51 PM +00:00 2012-05-25T20:39:51
None
  1. 50 shades of snot: The real reason stay-at-home moms are depressed

    A recent Gallup poll found that stay-home moms are more depressed than working moms. What, taking care of kids all day is hard? 

    5/25/2012 2:35:36 PM +00:00 2012-05-25T14:35:36
None
  1. Picasa

    Holy eyeballs! Pup holds record for largest eyes

    5/25/2012 8:05:59 PM +00:00 2012-05-25T20:05:59
None
  1. Frank Gunn / AP

    Did quitting 'Oprah' kill Oprah's reign?

    5/25/2012 4:22:27 PM +00:00 2012-05-25T16:22:27