1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: Will honesty cause twin boys to give up $50K?

  1. Transcript of: Will honesty cause twin boys to give up $50K?

    MATT LAUER, co-host: Now to what could become a costly lesson in honesty for two Minnesota brothers. It all began when an 11-year-old made an incredible $50,000 hockey shot at a charity event, but his twin was supposed to be the one who took it. Dave Berggren from the NBC affiliate KARE-TV is in Blaine , Minnesota , with details on this. Dave , good morning to you.

    DAVID BERGGREN reporting: Hey, good morning, Matt. You know, it is still being talked about here in Minnesota . We love our hockey stories. And you've seen it before. Fans get pulled down to take a half-court shot at a basketball game or kick a field goal at a football game . Well, in this case, it was an amazing center ice shot that went in for $50,000. But that cash still very much up in the air at this point. Who knows what's going to happen. Insurance company still trying to figure this out, and you'll find out why in just a moment. We'll give you some perspective on that shot in just a moment as well. But either way , cash or no cash, an amazing sports memory. What are the odds of this happening? An 89-foot shot into a tiny opening in the net. But it happened last Thursday in Faribault , Minnesota , and people who witnessed it couldn't believe it.

    Unidentified Man: I just was amazed. I just said, 'Oh, my gosh, it went in.'

    Unidentified Woman: Crowd went crazy. We were all screaming.

    BERGGREN: The incredible shot happened between periods at a celebrity hockey charity game. Fans paid 10 bucks for a chance to take a shot at a $50,000 prize, shooting a three-inch puck into a three-and-a-half-inch opening.

    Offscreen Voice: Nick Smith .

    BERGGREN: Nick Smith was the lucky name drawn, and from center ice the unbelievable shot went in.

    Mr. NATE SMITH: The crowd was going nuts.

    BERGGREN: But wait, it turns out this wasn't Nick Smith at all. It was his twin brother , Nate . Nick was outside of the building when his name was called, so their dad told Nate to take the shot.

    Mr. NATE SMITH: I know how to shoot and stuff...

    BERGGREN: Yeah.

    Mr. NATE SMITH: ...so I lined it up and, yeah.

    BERGGREN: So what was your reaction when you heard that your brother made it?

    Mr. NICK SMITH: Well, I went in the arena and my friend, he was like, ' Nathan just won $50,000.' And I 'm like, 'Yeah, right.' And then I walked in and Nathan 's sitting on -- Nathan was standing on the ice.

    BERGGREN: But after making the shot, the boys' father decided that honesty was the best policy and came clean with charity officials about the sibling switch and who really made the shot. And while officials decide whether the Smiths will get the $50,000, the twins already know what they'll do if they get to keep the money.

    Mr. NATE SMITH: Put most of it in our bank for college.

    BERGGREN: For college? OK. Maybe give some away?

    Mr. NICK SMITH: Yeah.

    BERGGREN: Yeah?

    Mr. NATE SMITH: Yeah. For our school, maybe buy some stuff and donate some stuff.

    BERGGREN: Cool. Well, people who saw the shot, who were witnessing that shot, said the place erupted like it was Game 7 , Stanley Cup final match. I spoke to the dad; he said, 'Hey, I looked around for Nick , couldn't find him. I sent Nate , not thinking in a million years that a shot would actually go in.' Well, the magic on the ice happened. Again, an 89-foot shot from center ice. You get one chance. Let's give you some perspective here. Yeah, go right, go right. You got to talk to it a little bit. Yeah, that's not happening. No cash coming my way either. Insurance company still trying to figure out what they'll decide. No word on whether they'll get the $50,000 or not. Either way , still pretty cool moment. Guys, back to you in New York .

    LAUER: It is, very cool moment. Dave Berggren , thank you very much . So, Savannah?

    SAVANNAH GUTHRIE, co-host: I say -- well, I would just give them the money. They were honest, they came forward. And it's not like they premeditated it, Matt. The dad said one kid was outside and then the other one was ready. Someone had to take the shot. Dad came forward.

    LAUER: As our executive producer, Jim Bell , says, 'First it's a hockey shot, then it's dates in high school . And then where does it go from there?'

    GUTHRIE: They're going to use the money for college, Matt.

Text: We're sorry. The text content of this page is no longer available.

Vote: Should twins get $50,000 hockey prize despite switch?

More on TODAY.com

None
  1. Retired cop: I know Zodiac Killer’s name

    video A former California highway patrolman has written a book in which he claims a 91-year-old man who died this year was the famed Zodiac Killer, who killed at least five people in the San Francisco area in the 1960s. NBC’s Mike Taibbi reports.

    5/26/2012 2:42:50 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:42:50
None
  1. TODAY

    video Do crying babies make you sharper?

    5/26/2012 2:39:26 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:39:26
None
  1. Biographer claims Prince William scarred by parent’s marriage

    video The author of a new book about the life of Prince William says that the royal most likely to ascend to the throne was scarred by his parent’s marital problems, and long-believed he might not ever settle down. NBC’s Duncan Golestani reports.

    5/26/2012 2:55:41 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:55:41
None
  1. TODAY

    video ‘Hunger Games’ comes to life?

    5/26/2012 2:46:43 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:46:43
None
  1. Stuntman falls 2,400 feet without chute

    video TODAY’s Jenna Wolfe speaks with stuntman Gary Connery, the first person to drop out of a helicopter wearing a “wing suit” and land without deploying a parachute.

    5/26/2012 2:45:01 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:45:01
None
  1. Is suspect in Etan Patz murder sane?

    video A lawyer for a 51-year-old New Jersey man accused of killing 6-year-old Etan Patz in New York City 33 years ago says his client has mental health problems that may come into play during his prosecution. Former FBI profiler Clint van Zandt discusses the case.

    5/26/2012 2:49:53 PM +00:00 2012-05-26T14:49:53